Advanced Training Series • Article Eleven

Adaptive Expertise: Why Is Routine Experience Not Enough for New Situations?

From mastering familiar tasks to responding to new situations

An employee may have many years of experience and carry out familiar tasks quickly and accurately, yet struggle when circumstances change or an unfamiliar problem arises. This shows that length of experience does not necessarily guarantee the ability to handle new situations.

By:Dr. Najwa bint Abdulrahim ShaheenGeneral Manager, Al-Itqan International for Training and Consulting
☰

Article contents

★

Core concepts

Routine Expertise

Routine expertise

Routine expertise, by contrast, focuses on mastering repetitive procedures and performing them faster, but may not prepare someone to deal with uncertainty, change and unprecedented problems.

Adaptive Expertise

Adaptive expertise

Relying excessively on written procedures.

Efficiency

Efficiency

Efficiency: performing familiar tasks quickly and accurately.

Innovation

Innovation

Innovation: developing new responses when standard procedures are insufficient.

06

Six practices for building adaptive expertise

01

First: Teach principles before procedures

Training should explain not only how to carry out each step, but why the steps were introduced, what purpose they serve and when they might be insufficient.

02

Second: Vary the contexts

Present the skill in different situations so learners do not associate it with only one case. This helps them identify what remains constant and what changes.

03

Third: Use incomplete problems

Present scenarios without all the information and ask learners to identify what else they need to know before deciding.

04

Fourth: Compare multiple solutions

Instead of asking only for the correct answer, have learners compare several options and identify their benefits, risks and conditions of use.

05

Fifth: Allow safe experimentation

Simulations and scenarios let learners try different responses, see their consequences and learn from mistakes without putting real work at risk.

06

Sixth: Discuss the reasoning process

Questions such as “Why did you choose this solution?” and “What might make you change your decision?” reveal learners’ reasoning and their flexibility in applying knowledge.

01

Introduction

An employee may have many years of experience and carry out familiar tasks quickly and accurately, yet struggle when circumstances change or an unfamiliar problem arises. This shows that length of experience does not necessarily guarantee the ability to handle new situations.

Experience can make people more efficient at repeating what they already know, but it can also become a constraint if it pushes them to apply familiar solutions to situations requiring different thinking.

This is where adaptive expertise comes in: the ability to use existing knowledge and experience flexibly, reshaping them to develop solutions appropriate for unfamiliar situations.

02

What Is Adaptive Expertise?

Adaptive expertise is the ability to balance two dimensions:

01

Efficiency: performing familiar tasks quickly and accurately.

02

Innovation: developing new responses when standard procedures are insufficient.

An adaptive expert does not disregard established rules or prior experience but does not treat them as fixed solutions for every situation. Instead, they understand the principles behind them and know when to apply, modify or replace a solution.

Routine expertise, by contrast, focuses on mastering repetitive procedures and performing them faster, but may not prepare someone to deal with uncertainty, change and unprecedented problems.

03

How Does Expertise Become Routine?

The more someone repeats a task, the easier and more automatic it becomes. This automaticity is useful because it saves time and effort and increases efficiency.

The problem begins when previous experience turns into a fixed lens through which every situation is viewed. A person may assume a new problem resembles an old one and apply the same solution without examining the differences.

Signs that routine expertise is taking over include:

01

Repeating past solutions without analyzing the context.

02

Resisting new methods simply because they are unfamiliar.

03

Relying excessively on written procedures.

04

Looking for a ready-made answer instead of diagnosing the problem.

05

Ignoring information that conflicts with prior experience.

06

Struggling with situations that lack clear instructions.

The routine expert asks: Which procedure have I used before?

The adaptive expert asks: What is the nature of this situation, and what will work now?

04

Adaptive Expertise Is Not Improvisation

Adaptive expertise does not mean ignoring regulations, making baseless decisions or changing procedures every time.

Innovation without knowledge can become reckless experimentation, while efficiency without flexibility leads to rigidity.

Adaptive expertise emerges when someone has a strong knowledge base and can then:

01

Understand the principles behind procedures.

02

Compare a new situation with previous experience.

03

Identify similarities and differences.

04

Test assumptions before accepting them.

05

Adjust a solution in light of the results.

06

Learn from feedback and mistakes.

Adaptive expertise therefore combines depth of knowledge with flexibility in using it.

05

Why Is Repeated Practice Not Enough?

When people practice only one kind of problem, under constant conditions and with a set solution, they may become highly efficient at that pattern without learning what to do when some elements change.

Repetition builds speed, but it does not automatically build adaptability.

To develop adaptive expertise, learners should encounter:

01

Problems that differ from the examples demonstrated.

02

Incomplete or changing information.

03

More than one plausible solution.

04

Situations that require interpretation rather than memorization.

05

Unexpected results that require revising a decision.

06

New constraints that rule out the usual solution.

In this way, learners use knowledge as a tool for thinking rather than a ready-made recipe to follow.

06

How Can We Design Training That Builds Adaptive Expertise?

First: Teach principles before procedures

Training should explain not only how to carry out each step, but why the steps were introduced, what purpose they serve and when they might be insufficient.

Second: Vary the contexts

Present the skill in different situations so learners do not associate it with only one case. This helps them identify what remains constant and what changes.

Third: Use incomplete problems

Present scenarios without all the information and ask learners to identify what else they need to know before deciding.

Fourth: Compare multiple solutions

Instead of asking only for the correct answer, have learners compare several options and identify their benefits, risks and conditions of use.

Fifth: Allow safe experimentation

Simulations and scenarios let learners try different responses, see their consequences and learn from mistakes without putting real work at risk.

Sixth: Discuss the reasoning process

Questions such as “Why did you choose this solution?” and “What might make you change your decision?” reveal learners’ reasoning and their flexibility in applying knowledge.

07

Applications in Corporate Training

Adaptive expertise is needed in many areas, including:

01

Training leaders to manage complex situations without ready-made solutions.

02

Training project teams to respond to changing requirements and resources.

03

Training customer service teams to handle cases outside standard procedures.

04

Training quality teams to analyze new problems rather than classify them automatically.

05

Training crisis teams to make decisions with incomplete information.

06

Training employees to use emerging technologies as they continue to evolve.

In these areas, employees must not only know what worked before, but assess whether it is still appropriate under current conditions.

08

The Role of the Workplace in Building Adaptive Expertise

Training alone cannot produce an adaptive expert when the workplace punishes every new attempt, discourages questions or regards a thoughtful departure from routine as a mistake.

Adaptive expertise requires an environment that:

01

Allows assumptions to be discussed.

02

Provides room for controlled experimentation.

03

Documents lessons learned from new situations.

04

Rewards learning and improvement, not just speed.

05

Enables knowledge-sharing across disciplines.

06

Distinguishes negligence from mistakes arising from responsible experimentation.

Adaptability cannot grow in an environment that demands innovation and then punishes every unexpected outcome.

09

When Do Efforts to Build Adaptive Expertise Fail?

Training may fail when learners face complex situations before acquiring essential knowledge, or when open-ended problems are presented without feedback.

It can also fail when variety becomes an end in itself, or when learners are asked to invent solutions that violate regulations or professional boundaries.

Adaptive expertise should therefore be developed gradually: learners first master the basics, then face increasing variety, test multiple solutions and learn to revise decisions based on evidence.

10

Conclusion

Long experience is valuable, but not enough when the future differs from the past. It may help people perform familiar tasks efficiently, without ensuring they can understand new situations or reconstruct solutions.

Adaptive expertise makes knowledge more flexible, turning earlier experience from a fixed template into a resource that can be reorganized to fit the situation.

Training should therefore aim not merely to produce an employee who performs a procedure flawlessly, but to develop a professional who understands principles, notices change, learns from outcomes and knows when to rely on experience and when to reconsider it.

A true expert is not someone with a ready-made answer to every problem, but someone who can build the right solution when familiar solutions are no longer enough.

11

References

1.الرشودي، أثير، وزارع، نسرين. (2026). أسلوبا التعلّم العميق والتعلّم السطحي كمنبئين بالخبرة التكيفية لدى طالبات الدراسات العليا بجامعة القصيم. مجلة البحوث التربوية والنوعية.

2.السلمي، مفلح بن حامد. (2025). القيادة التكيفية ودورها في إدارة الأزمات في المنظمات. المجلة العربية للإدارة، المجلد 45، العدد الثالث، ص 307–332.

3.حسن، نسرين فاروق معوض. (2023). تقييم البرامج الفندقية لمواجهة ظاهرة تغير المناخ وأثرها على الأداء التكيفي للعاملين في الفنادق. مجلة البحوث الإدارية، المجلد 41، العدد الثاني، ص 1–29.

12

Stay connected

Reproduction for teaching, training, and research is permitted with attribution to the author and preservation of the article’s meaning and references.

Practical principleExpertise is valuable not because it repeats the same solution, but because it identifies what suits the situation and adapts when circumstances change.