The Management Philosophy of Excellence and Itqan
How do values become decisions, responsibilities, processes and measurable results? An exploration of leadership, the EFQM Model and the ethics of excellence.
Contents
Key Concepts
Organizational Values
Ethical and professional standards that guide decisions and conduct: trustworthiness, justice, excellence in action and respect for beneficiaries' rights.
Supportive Leadership
Clarifying purpose and responsibilities, providing resources and authority, and listening to evidence for improvement.
Systems Thinking
Seeing processes, variation and human factors as interconnected parts that can be improved.
Organizational Excellence
Alignment between an organization's direction, the execution of its strategy, and results demonstrating achievement of its objectives.
From Values to Results: An Organizational Alignment Map
Values
Ethical purpose: trustworthiness, justice and the rights of beneficiaries
Leadership
Translating values into priorities, resources and authority
Processes
Clear procedures and practices with actionable responsibilities
Results
Evidence, measurement, review and continual improvement
When Itqan Becomes the Basis for Decision-Making
An organization's philosophy is visible in its daily decisions: how it sets priorities, responds to errors, and balances achievement against the rights of beneficiaries and employees. The philosophy of excellence and Itqan therefore concerns both the purpose guiding work and the system that turns this purpose into practices open to evaluation.
Having established the concept of quality in the first article, we now examine the relationship between values, leadership, processes and results. The central premise is that professional commitment needs a supportive organizational environment, while procedures need a meaningful purpose that gives them value.
The Ethical Dimension in Practice
Itqan can be understood as a commitment to performing work carefully, respecting beneficiaries' rights and describing results truthfully. In Arab and Islamic traditions, trustworthiness, justice and ihsan (doing good with excellence) give this commitment ethical depth. These values can be translated into concrete conduct, such as clear service terms, information protection and fairness in assessment.
It would be incorrect to assume that global management models overlook people or values. ISO's quality management principles include leadership, engagement of people and relationship management, alongside improvement and evidence-based decision-making. Depending on an organization's context, these foundations can complement local values. [1]
Leadership That Creates the Conditions for Excellence
Leadership supports quality by clarifying purpose and responsibilities, providing resources and training, and listening to those who do the work. Demanding results without understanding employees' constraints may obscure the causes of deficiencies rather than address them.
Deming's thinking highlights the importance of viewing the organization as an interconnected system and understanding variation, learning and human factors. This perspective shifts attention from finding someone to blame for every setback toward identifying improvable causes in the system, while maintaining clear professional accountability. [2]
One proposed practice is for leadership to hold a periodic meeting on improvement opportunities, hear evidence and suggestions, and assign an owner and follow-up date to each action. Such participation needs defined authority and boundaries so that empowerment becomes organized action.
From Philosophy to Organizational Excellence
The EFQM Model helps examine an organization through three interconnected dimensions: Direction, Execution and Results. They address why the organization exists and where it is heading, how it delivers its purpose and strategy, and what it achieves. [3]
The value of this connection lies in showing consistency between what an organization says, does and measures. An organization may claim to prioritize beneficiaries while imposing complicated procedures that ignore their needs; review then offers an opportunity to identify the gap and what should change.
Using an excellence framework does not mean that completing its forms proves excellence has been achieved. Judgment requires evidence that practices are implemented and effective, and results appropriate to the organization's context and performance trends.
Governance and Learning: A Practical Example
Suppose a training center receives an objection to an assessment result. Excellence starts with published criteria, an understandable appeal process, an impartial confidential review, and communication explaining the decision. If objections recur, the team examines the clarity of the assessment tool, consistency among assessors and adequacy of guidance.
This example combines the value of justice, leadership responsibility, process control and learning from results. It is a proposed illustration, not a report of an actual incident or evidence that any particular procedure is effective.
From this perspective, the author proposes the 'Arab Itqan Model for Sustainable Excellence' as an intellectual concept combining clarity of purpose, integrity, process efficiency, staff participation and evidence-based learning. Turning it into an operational model would require defining its elements and indicators, testing it and evaluating it; it is not presented here as an accredited framework.
Conclusion
The philosophy of Itqan takes root when employees see organizational values reflected in decisions and procedures, and beneficiaries experience their effect in the service. One starting point is to examine a consequential decision: which value underlies it, and how is that value reflected in execution and measurement?
The next article explores the historical development of quality thinking and how its practices expanded from inspection to system-wide management and improvement.
References
[1] ISO — Quality Management Principleshttps://www.iso.org/quality-management/principles
[2] The Deming Institute — System of Profound Knowledgehttps://deming.org/explore/sopk/
[3] EFQM — The EFQM Modelhttps://efqm.org/the-efqm-model/
Stay Connected
Reproduction for educational, training and research purposes is permitted, provided the author is credited and the meaning and references are preserved.
Add New Comment